Al-Tahrir: Jurnal Pemikiran Islam is committed to maintaining editorial independence, academic integrity, and impartiality throughout its scholarly publishing processes.
The journal ensures that editorial decisions are made independently and are based on the academic quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and ethical standards of submitted manuscripts.
Editorial independence is essential to maintaining the credibility, transparency, and scholarly integrity of the journal. The publisher, institutional management, sponsors, and other external parties must respect the professional judgment and editorial authority of the journal's editorial team.
The Editor-in-Chief has primary responsibility for the journal's editorial direction and final decisions regarding manuscript publication.
Editorial decisions concerning acceptance, revision, or rejection are made based on:
The originality and scholarly contribution of the manuscript.
Its relevance to the journal's focus and scope.
The quality of its theoretical framework and methodology.
The accuracy and validity of its analysis and findings.
The quality of its academic presentation and references.
The results and recommendations of the peer-review process.
Compliance with the journal's publication ethics and editorial policies.
The Editor-in-Chief may delegate specific editorial responsibilities to authorized editors while retaining overall responsibility for the integrity of the editorial process.
Although Al-Tahrir is published by Universitas Islam Negeri Kiai Ageng Muhammad Besari Ponorogo, editorial decisions are made independently by the journal's authorized editorial team.
The publisher and institutional management provide administrative, financial, technical, and organizational support without interfering with individual manuscript evaluations or editorial decisions.
No institutional official, administrative unit, sponsor, or external party may require the journal to accept, reject, prioritize, or modify a manuscript for reasons unrelated to its academic merit and compliance with publication standards.
The publisher respects the authority of the Editor-in-Chief in determining the scholarly content of the journal.
Al-Tahrir promotes objective and responsible scholarly communication in Islamic studies and related disciplines.
The journal does not allow political, ideological, religious, commercial, or personal interests to determine editorial outcomes.
Manuscripts are evaluated according to scholarly standards regardless of the authors' institutional affiliations, academic positions, nationality, gender, personal background, or viewpoints.
The journal welcomes diverse academic perspectives and encourages critical, evidence-based, and intellectually responsible scholarly discussion.
The journal applies a double-blind peer-review process to support objective and impartial manuscript evaluation.
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts based on their academic quality, originality, methodological soundness, relevance, and contribution to the field.
Editors must ensure that reviewer recommendations are considered fairly and that editorial decisions are not influenced by personal relationships, institutional affiliations, or external pressure.
Where conflicts of interest arise, the relevant editor must disclose the conflict and withdraw from the affected editorial decision-making process.
Editors, reviewers, and other individuals involved in the editorial process must disclose any potential conflicts of interest that may compromise their objectivity.
Potential conflicts may include:
Personal or professional relationships with authors.
Institutional or organizational affiliations that may affect impartiality.
Financial or commercial interests related to the submitted manuscript.
Academic competition or collaboration that may influence judgment.
Personal, political, or ideological interests that could affect editorial decisions.
The journal will take appropriate measures to manage disclosed conflicts and ensure that manuscripts are evaluated by impartial and qualified individuals.
All manuscripts submitted to Al-Tahrir are treated as confidential documents throughout the editorial and peer-review processes.
Editors, reviewers, and editorial staff must not disclose unpublished manuscript content, reviewer identities, editorial discussions, or confidential communications to unauthorized parties.
Information obtained during the editorial process must not be used for personal, academic, commercial, or other purposes outside the responsibilities of the journal.
Editorial decisions must not be reversed, altered, or influenced solely because of external pressure, institutional interests, financial considerations, or disagreement with the scholarly conclusions of a manuscript.
Any reconsideration of an editorial decision must follow the journal's established editorial procedures and be supported by legitimate academic or ethical grounds.
Authors who disagree with editorial decisions may submit an appeal in accordance with the journal's Complaints and Appeals Policy.
The Editor-in-Chief and editorial team are responsible for maintaining editorial independence and ensuring that the journal's policies are implemented consistently.
The editorial team must:
Apply editorial standards fairly and consistently.
Maintain transparency in manuscript evaluation and publication decisions.
Manage conflicts of interest appropriately.
Protect the confidentiality of authors and reviewers.
Ensure that editorial decisions are based on academic merit.
Address concerns regarding editorial misconduct or undue influence.
The publisher and journal management support these responsibilities by providing an appropriate institutional environment for independent editorial operations.
This policy is reviewed periodically to ensure its continued relevance and consistency with recognized principles of scholarly publishing and publication ethics.
Any concerns regarding violations of editorial independence may be reported to the journal through its official contact channels.
Al-Tahrir is committed to protecting editorial autonomy as a fundamental principle of trustworthy academic publishing.